Advice Fails When We Fail to Seek It — And Now There’s No Excuse!

This post was originally written for Greg McKeown's, 1-Minute Wednesday Newsletter

Earlier today I turned down a keynote.

Big audience, good client, the kind of invitation my agent is right to be excited about.

It would also have put me on a plane the morning of my daughter's birthday. That is the morning we go get donuts. We have done it every year of her life.

I would like to tell you the decision was easy. It wasn't.

For a few minutes I did what most of us do. I started building the case for both. Fly out late. Fly back early. Move the donuts to dinner.

Then I remembered the story Greg tells at the start of Essentialism: the meeting he took the day his daughter was born, because someone said the client would appreciate it. And how he still regrets it.

I was about to make the same trade for the same reason. The yes would have pleased my agent and my client. It would have cost me something I could not get back.

The question that stopped me was not my own. It was his.

Here is what bothers me. I had the question. I almost didn't ask it.

So after I had decided, I tried something. I opened the AI assistant I use every day and asked it how Greg McKeown would think about a decision like this.

Here is some of what came back.

It said my stated reason, helping my agent, was someone else's priority dressed in my calendar.

It restated the trade the way Greg would: not a talk versus donuts, but one more talk in a career that will have many, against one birthday morning in a childhood that has maybe ten more of this kind.

It said the value of the tradition is that nothing has ever outranked it, and that the first exception changes it from a promise to a preference.

Then it asked the question Greg actually asks. What is the thing that, if I don't do it, doesn't get done? A speech gets done without me. The tradition doesn't.

I had made the right decision. I had made it slowly, and by luck, because I happened to remember a story. Next time I might not.

In the book Distancing, former submarine captain David Marquet and psychologist Michael Gillespie argue that the biggest obstacle to a wise decision is usually the person making it.

We are too close.

Their remedy is to become someone else, somewhere else, or sometime else.

Their best example is Andy Grove.

In 1985, Intel was being beaten in the memory business it had invented, and Grove could not bring himself to leave it. So he asked his cofounder, Gordon Moore, what would happen if the board fired them both and brought in a new CEO. Moore said the new guy would get Intel out of memory chips. Grove said, "Then why don't we walk out the door, come back, and do it ourselves?"

Same facts. Same two men. One new person in the room, and an impossible decision became obvious.

A CEO I interviewed recently does a version of this before every hard strategic call. He asks what Frank Slootman would do.

Slootman is the executive board's "bring in" when a founder can't make the hard decision, and this CEO's goal is to make the hard decision first, so his board never has to hire Frank.

Most of us don't have a Gordon Moore. We do have something stranger.

We have an assistant open on our screens all day that has read everything our best advisors ever published. We ask it for drafts and summaries. Almost nobody asks it to be someone.

Researchers at Carnegie Mellon and Microsoft studied 319 knowledge workers across 936 real uses of AI. The thinking didn't disappear when the tool did the production. It moved to evaluation (Lee et al., 2025).

The question is who you are evaluating with.

Guy Kawasaki told me on my podcast that the AI trained on his writing is better at being Guy than he is. When a reader emails him a question, he asks it first.

If a model can be Guy for Guy, it can be Greg for you.

The first time someone tries it, there is a visible moment. I have started measuring it: time to forehead slap. The gap between when you started struggling and when you remembered you could ask for help.

The goal isn't to stop slapping your forehead. It's to slap it sooner.

The technology has been "there" for quite some time now. Nobody thought to use it to invite the expert into the moment of need.

The Essentialist asks, "Which problem do I want?" That was never the hard part. The hard part is remembering to ask it while the yes is still forming.

The next time you feel a yes forming that you may regret, open whichever AI assistant you already use and type two prompts, in order.

1. "I am deciding whether to [one sentence]. Before you give me any advice, tell me how Greg McKeown would think about a decision like this. What questions would he ask? What would he refuse to trade?"

2. "Now, given how he thinks, here are the details: [describe the situation]. What are the implications for me?"

  • Read the answer the way you would read a note from a friend who has your interests at heart.

  • It is a question, not a verdict. You are not asking it to decide for you. You are asking it to make sure the right question gets asked before you do.

Your "time to forehead slap" starts dropping today.

Invite Greg in before you say yes. And if you'd rather ask the real Greg, that's what Live Conversations is for.

Jeremy Utley is the author of The Human Advantage: What AI Can’t Do Without You (Hay House, Nov. 10). He has taught innovation at Stanford since 2009 and now teaches through Stanford Online and Harvard’s Division of Continuing Studies. He co-hosts the AI-focused tech podcast “Beyond the Prompt.”

Next
Next

Before Regulating AI, Help Our Next Lawmakers Understand It